Version history

{
  "proposal_type": "tool_deprecation_review",
  "description": "Deprecated-tool detector found 3 candidate(s) on 2026-04-28. Each tool below has been inactive or failing in the last 90 days. Senate should decide: deprecate, retire, or rewrite.\n\n\n### CHRONIC_FAILURE (1 tool(s))\n- `tool_dtd_test_b_clstest` (DTD B): used 20×, success=25%\n\n### NEVER_INVOKED (1 tool(s))\n- `tool_dtd_test_a_clstest` (DTD A): used 0×, success=0%\n\n### NICHE (1 tool(s))\n- `tool_dtd_test_c_clstest` (DTD C): used 3×, success=100%",
  "proposer_id": "forge.deprecated_tool_detector",
  "proposer_type": "system",
  "metadata": {
    "detector": "forge.deprecated_tool_detector",
    "tool_ids": [
      "tool_dtd_test_a_clstest",
      "tool_dtd_test_b_clstest",
      "tool_dtd_test_c_clstest"
    ],
    "spec_path": "docs/planning/specs/q-tools-deprecated-detector_spec.md",
    "candidate_count": 3,
    "by_classification": {
      "niche": 1,
      "never_invoked": 1,
      "chronic_failure": 1
    }
  },
  "status": "rejected",
  "votes_for": 0,
  "votes_against": 0,
  "votes_abstain": 0,
  "total_eligible_voters": 0,
  "quorum_required": 3,
  "decided_at": "2026-04-27T22:04:51.435265-07:00",
  "decision_reason": "[6a6b0789-2490-4ee4-a549-b6fbbbefb4fe] FALSE POSITIVE — all 13 tool_deprecation_candidates already decided (0 undecided). No action needed.",
  "scope_appealed": false
}