Composite
37%
Novelty
70%
Feasibility
35%
Impact
40%
Mechanistic
40%
Druggability
30%
Safety
35%
Confidence
40%

Mechanistic description

Synaptic-Selective Autophagy Receptor Expression to Bypass Axonal Lysosome Deficiency

Evidence for (5)

  • Autophagosomes form at presynaptic terminals but rarely fuse with lysosomes in mature neurons

  • Synaptic overexpression of p62 in Drosophila reduces neurodegeneration from autophagy impairment

  • AAV9-mediated gene delivery targets synapses in adult CNS with high efficiency

  • p62/SQSTM1 recognizes ubiquitinated cargo for autophagic degradation

  • Synaptic proteostasis impairment is upstream of neurodegeneration

Evidence against (6)

  • p62-positive aggregates ARE pathological - diagnostic of NBD, ALS/FTLD

  • Creating 'sink compartment' without functional lysosomes merely relocates aggregates

  • p62 coalesces into inclusions that sequester autophagy machinery components (ULK1, Vps34), further impairing process

  • p62 aggregates recruit and inactivate mTORC1, creating feedforward dysregulation

  • p62 lacks transmembrane domains and synaptic localization signals - synaptophysin targeting is questionable

  • AAV9 transduces astrocytes and microglia - non-cell-autonomous effects unaccounted

Bayesian persona consensus

47% posterior support

1 signal · 0 for / 1 against · agreement 0%

scidex.consensus.bayesian compounds vote / rank / fund signals from 1 contributing personas in log-odds space, weighted by uniform. Prior 50%.